Sadly, I love this polish. It’s sad because I still don’t know what it’s called! And it freaks out my camera so much that I’m not sure it would be easy to find color accurate swatches to compare it to. This is actually a little lighter than the picture shows. I haven’t yet come across an actual Finger Paints jelly, but I’ve got several of these that are sort of a creme/jelly hybrid, it’s a weird finish – like a very opaque jelly. 2 coats.
Thanks, you guys, for making suggestions!
OK, 2 votes for Coral Collage, 1 for Drawn To This Color, and one for Original Orange. OMG I’m never going to figure this out, it’s driving me crazy!
It’s hard to tell based on online swatches, but I’d think it’s “Original Orange”
I have a Finger Paints coral that looks a exactly like that with that jelly-ish finish. It’s called Coral Collage. I’m not 100% that’s what you have but it looks very similar. I got it last summer.